Skip to content

Catholicism’s “Marvelous” Unity; and Blowing Up Bridges

June 12, 2014
When I Saw Her, I Marveled Greatly
Christian unity is a persuasive argument used to convert  evangelicals to Catholicism. Here is testimony of former evangelical Russell Stutler, at
“What happens when Christians reject the authority of Peter’s successor? Today there are over 30,000 Protestant denominations and independent churches, each with its own interpretation of the Bible, and the number keeps growing…I finally realized that I had to end my own church hopping and submit to the teaching authority of the one church that Jesus built on a rock, with the direct successors to Peter and the apostles still leading it under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.”


Rome claims to be the one, true church. “For it is through Christ’s Catholic Church alone, which is the universal help toward salvation, that the fullness of the means of salvation can be obtained.”[1]  Rome claims a unity in the one faith received from the apostles; she claims unity of divine worship, through the sacraments; and she claims historical unity (based on apostolic succession) with one head, the Pope. There is also a uniformity of liturgy that promotes solidarity. When you eat at McDonald’s, you know what to expect. Similarly, wherever you attend mass you can expect the same liturgy to occur.


Is Christian unity to be found in Roman Catholicism? What does Catholic unity look like? We shall explore nine marks that distinguish the unity of Catholicism. Then, we will answer the charge of Evangelical disunity. 


Mark #1: It is an Adulterous Unity


According to Rome, every sincere person alive in the world today belongs, however imperfectly, to the Roman Catholic Church. 


“All men are called to this catholic unity of the People of God…And to it, in different ways, belong or are ordered: the Catholic faithful, others who believe in Christ, and finally all mankind…Those who believe in Christ and have been properly baptized are put in a certain, although imperfect, communion with the Catholic Church…The plan of salvation also includes those who acknowledge the Creator, in the first place amongst whom are the Muslims…Those who, through no fault of their own, do not know the Gospel of Christ or his Church, but who nevertheless seek God with a sincere heart…who try in their actions to do his will as they know it through the dictates of their conscience — those too may achieve eternal salvation.” [2]


Jesus says that we must enter through the narrow way – by trusting in Him alone. Catholicism promotes her broad way, either through ceremonial water baptism or in the case of unbelievers, a “baptism of desire.” It is a mystery how Muslims and unbelievers are part of the Body of Christ. Nevertheless, Rome claims that it is so. Rome commits “spiritual adultery” when she incorporates unbelievers into her fold. An example of her flirtatious behavior occurred in 1986 at the World Day of Prayer in Assisi: video here. So, Rome’s unity is inclusive and adulterous. True unity is exclusive and chaste.


Mark #2: It is an Impure Unity


How do you bind together an inclusive “church?” The unity of Roman Catholicism is not an organic unity of like-minded believers in Jesus, who is our Vine. Rather, it is a syncretistic union that exists by the permissiveness of Rome. J.A. Wiley writes, “As a corporation, having its head at Rome, and stretching it limbs to the extremities of the earth, she is of gigantic bulk and imposing appearance; but, closely examined, she is seen to be an assemblage of heterogeneous materials, held together simply by the compression of force. It is a coercive power from without, not an attractive influence from within that gives her being and form… It is combination, not incorporation; union, not unity, that characterizes the Church of Rome.”[3]


The entry (overnight) of countless unconverted pagans into the Church at the time of Constantine; the inclusion of unconverted Africans and Native Americans, who practice animism mixed with Catholicism; Dominicans opposing Franciscans; Jesuits battling Benedictines. Liberation theologians. Sedevacantists. What are all these various orders and branches, if not the result of Rome’s laissez faire attitude toward impurity? As long as each group is willing to remain within the huge tent of Rome, under the infallible papa, there is no compelling reason for family discipline. Catholicism, post Vatican II, is an extremely ambiguous religion. A Georgetown University survey in 2008 found that: 43% of Catholics do not believe that Jesus is really present in the eucharist; 88% of Catholics do not attend mass on Holy Days of Obligation; and 74% of Catholics do not go to Confession at least once a year, the minimum required by the Church! Clearly the majority of Catholics are RINO – Romish in Name Only. Catholic unity is an impure mirage.


Mark #3: It is a Lying Unity


In order to appear credible and desirable, Catholicism must have a veneer of truth. So the basic fundamentals of Christianity are found in Her. There is a growing movement toward unity based on the idea of “mere Christianity.” Since both Protestants and Catholics agree on the historic creeds, godly separation based on truth is deemed “scandalous.” Division is now considered to be the sinful wounding of the Body of Christ. Rome has the same “cast of characters” as revealed in God’s word (a self-existent and eternal Jehovah; a trinity of the Godhead; a mankind made in God’s image; a fall of Adam; a redemption of mankind by the incarnate Jesus; His death, resurrection and ascension; and His bodily return at the Last Day). But the interpretations and applications of these realities are diametrically opposed to true Christianity. Catholicism’s truth claims are superseded by layer upon layer of error. Rome claims that the Bible is the revelation of God, but contradicts the Word by adding a second source of divine revelation, Sacred Tradition. She usurps Christ’s authority with her popes, priests and wafers. Rome claims to control the Holy Spirit, calling Him down during baptisms and confirmations. The reality is that Catholicism holds sacred truths only to further her idolatrous lies.


There are many means that Rome has used to spread counterfeit unity. A recent tactic, quite powerful, is to enter into ecumenical agreements that are written deceptively. Then the agreements are used to further her aim of global religious and secular dominion. There is a lying spirit sent into the world, claiming to be the Queen of Heaven, that promotes Catholicism. And Rome uses her political power to entice evangelical organizations to join with her to fight the “culture wars.” The Catholic Church is utilitarian. The end justifies the means. The end is the promotion of a false, compromising,  and wicked unity under the papacy. The means are “whatever works” in the furtherance of her megalomania. Historically, Rome used forged documents to support her claim of apostolic succession (False Decretals) and her temporal dominion (Donation of Constantine). Many of the writings of the so-called “Church Fathers,” used to support extra-biblical doctrines, have been found to be forged or taken out of context. In short, she exhibits unity only through lies and counterfeits.


Mark #4: It is a Degrading Unity


God gave us our intellects to enable us to pursue the light of His truth. How can Rome assure the least controversy within the fold of her religion? She has declared herself to be infallible in all matters touching faith and morals. All discussion is over: Rome has spoken! The Pope, by virtue of his office, is infallible. He has “full, supreme, and universal power over the whole Church, a power that he can always exercise unhindered.” [4] The teaching of the Church (her Magisterium) is also infallible. As a result of this infallibility, faithful Catholics everywhere are taught to submit entirely to the religious hierarchy.  “Religious submission of the intellect and will must be given to a doctrine which the Supreme Pontiff or the college of bishops declares concerning faith or morals when they exercise the authentic magisterium, even if they do not intend to proclaim it by definitive act.”[5]  Priests must submit their minds and wills to their bishops by a vow of obedience. Bishops must submit their minds and wills in obedience to their superiors, on up to the pope. In such a manner, unity is promoted. But at what cost?


Historically, Rome endeavored to keep the Scriptures out of the hands of the laity, lest they be enticed to private judgment that might contradict her teaching. The Bible for centuries was included on Rome’s Index of Forbidden Books. She is like a helicopter parent, hoping to control all her children’s actions. To further ensure no conflicts arise that might endanger unity, she set up a system to keep “heretical” writings out of the hands of her children. All Catholic religious materials are censored. They must be granted the “Good Housekeeping seal of approval”: the Nihil Obstat and the Imprimatur


Wylie writes: “Put out the eyes of men, and there will be only one opinion about colour; extinguish the understandings of men, and there will be but one opinion regarding religion. This is what Rome does. With her rod of infallibility she touches the intellect and the conscience, and benumbs them into torpor.”[6]  Rome claims to “sit as Queen” of the conscience and intellect. She even expects dominion over the senses, telling her followers to deny the reality “bread and wine” and believe “body, blood, soul, and divinity.” In so doing, she degrades her followers.


Mark #5: It is an Enforced Unity


Having obtained submission of intellect and will from her subjects, Rome saw only one danger to unity. This danger is the light of truth that shines out of authentic Christians who dare to ignore her infallible fulminations. An important biblical doctrine is that of the remnant. From the time of the Roman persecution by the Caesars to the great outpouring of grace at the time of the Reformation, there has been a godly people that remained separate from the infallible “Church.” The Christians hidden in the Roman catacombs; the Ambrosians of the fourth through the eighth centuries; the Paulicians of the East; followed by the Waldensians and Albigenes who were hidden in the valleys of the Alps; the Wycliffites and Lollards of England; and the Hussites of Bohemia.


Rome set out with a vengeance to persecute and slaughter those peoples who dared to question her authority. The slaughter of the Albigenses (see Beziers), the founding of the Medieval Inquisition, the interdiction of England, and the wars against the Bohemians were some of the ways Rome sought to extinguish the light of the gospel. At the Reformation she redoubled her efforts, slaughtering the Huguenots of France (see St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre), hunting down all Protestants that she could using her inquisitions and treachery. The Society of Jesus was founded by Ignatius of Loyola to submit to and defend the papacy using all means necessary, including political espionage and assassinations.


There is no denying history. Rome has been a staunch opponent to religious liberty, and has persecuted the Church of Jesus Christ.


Mark #6: It is a Man-Made Unity


Investigation of the rise of the Roman spiritual empire reveals that it has always sought a man-made unity. This is a reflection of the human urge that commenced at the fall, when Eve succumbed to the serpent’s temptation (when you eat of it your eyes will be opened, and you will be like God). After the flood, we see this urge in the construction of the Tower of Babel (Come, let us build ourselves a city and a tower in the heavens, and let us make a name for ourselves). Rome follows suit, using building materials from three great civilizations: the Jews, the Greeks, and the Romans. From the Jews, Rome recreated the forms of the Jewish religion (that were meant to be only types pointing to fulfillment by Jesus). The Judaizing combination of faith and works, the physical temple, ceremonies and law-keeping, a priesthood, and a sacrificial system all descended from Israel to Rome. From the Greeks, Rome has built a philosophical system by which to amalgamate and justify her doctrines. And from Pagan Rome she has rebuilt Caesar and his pagan superstitions, from the design of miraculous medals, relics and scapulars to the intercession of dead men and women.


Wylie writes: “The Papacy is the most wonderful of all human systems. It stands alone, unrivalled and unapproached, throwing all former systems of error into the shade…The ancient polytheisms were comparatively simple in their plan and tolerant in their spirit. Not so the Papacy. It selects the worst passions of our nature, –the sensuality of the appetites, the idolatry of the heart, the love of wealth, the lust of dominion, pride, ambition, the desire to dictate the faith of others. It gives these passions the largest development of which they are capable; it combines and arranges them with exquisite skill, and thus enables them to act with the greatest effect. It is the most powerful organization that ever existed on the side of error and against the truth.”[7]


Rome is the “City of Man”; she opposes the “City of God.”


Mark #7: It is a Temporal Unity


In order to better accomplish her mission of domination, Rome has sought to combine the sacred with the secular. She has employed her armies. She has wielded authority over kings and princes since before the time of Charlemagne even to the present day. The Holy See is a religio-political entity, sending and receiving ambassadors to all nations. [The United States held out until 1984, when Ronald Reagan appointed the first ambassador to Rome]. Rome has terrorized entire nations with spiritual threats, denying her sacraments to entire nations until their leaders submitted to her authority (see interdicts). She has entered into concordats with numerous nations, seeking favorable treatment from governments in exchange for her influence. She received 1.75 billion lire through a concordat with Mussolini, and hundreds of millions of dollars arising from the concordat with Hitler. The Pope and his ambassadors travel the world, networking with politicians, and influencing foreign governments.


We see the strategy of combining the spiritual with the temporal in Rome’s attempts at ecumenical unity today. Two of her most ambitious projects are with Pentecostals and with politically conservative evangelicals. Both projects place the temporal over the spiritual. Pope Francis recently begged for unity with Pentecostals in a video he recorded for a Kenneth Copeland conference. He also requested prayer and asked for their blessing. “Be blessed!” bellowed Copeland and the leaders of Pentecostalism over and over in response to the pope’s request. In 1994 the notorious “Evangelicals and Catholics Together” movement was founded, which seeks unity in order to promote co-belligerence in the culture wars. This was followed in 2009 by the Manhattan Declaration, (or should it be called “City of Man”-hattan?) with similar cultural aims.


What does the Pope seek to get in returns for his ecumenical overtures? The compromise of the Gospel of Jesus Christ: the only thing standing in the way of Rome’s global supremacy.


It is a fundamental principal of the Papacy that the pope is Vicar of Christ on earth. Since Christ is both Head of the Church and King of Kings, the pope, as His sole representative on earth seeks both roles. By divine right he holds himself both bishop of bishops and king of kings. Wylie writes: “The object of the Papacy is, in brief, to exalt a man, or rather a class of men, to the supreme, undivided, and absolute control of the world and its affairs.”[8]


Mark #8: It is a Spiritually Impotent Unity


The gospel of Jesus Christ is “the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes.” Rom. 1:16. By the sovereign and mighty power of the Holy Spirit, men and women are born from above, die to self and are a new creation in Christ. We “like living stones are being built up as a spiritual house, to be a holy priesthood, to offer spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ.” 1Pet. 2:5. Those redeemed by Jesus belong to the City of God – we are citizens of heaven. But those who belong to the City of Man are bereft of heavenly spiritual power. That is not to say that they are without power, for the Evil One, the god of this world, gives out temporal powers within his dominion.


The counterfeit Roman religion has “the appearance of godliness, but denies its power.” 2 Tim. 3:5. We can bear Rome witness that she “has a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge.” She is bereft of spiritual light. She is a religion of dead idols, that like the lifeless Dagon must fall down before the true God. 1 Sam. 5:3. Looking at the distinctive doctrines of Rome, we find that there is:

  • No power…in a baptism that doesn’t regenerate
  • No power…in praying to saints who are doubly dead
  • No power…in priests who usurp the authority of Jesus
  • No power…in a fallible pope and magisterium
  • No power…in superstitious sacramentals
  • No power…in the idolatrous wafer-god of transubstantiation
  • No power…in the intercession of the false Queen Mary
  • No power…in moldy relics
  • No power…in indulgences, masses and penances
  • No power…in last rites
  • No power…in a false gospel that condemns its adherents

There is no spiritual power in the adulterous, impure, lying, degrading, persecuting, man-made, and temporally united religion of Rome – headed by the Pope. Where does one find true spiritual power? In the chaste, holy, honest, discriminating, persecuted, God-ordained, and spiritual church – headed by Jesus Himself.


Mark #9: It is a Condemned Unity


Does God warn us in His Word about a wealthy, pompous, religio-political, worldwide entity, headquartered in Rome, that would arise and enter into adulterous spiritual trysts, declare herself  sovereign over all humanity, degrade her followers, with doctrines founded on truth but entirely distorted by man-made traditions which are spiritually powerless, and who persecutes the saints of God? Why, yes! There is such a woman presented in chapters 17-20 of the book of Revelation. She is the woman wearing precious jewels, adorned in purple and scarlet, described as “Mystery, Babylon” (the great city of man), who is seated on seven hills (the Holy See of Rome), yet seated on many waters (wielding worldwide political power), with whom the politicians of the earth commit sexual immorality. She makes drunk her degraded followers, invents doctrines of demons, and is drunk with the blood of the saints. Does this not describe perfectly the Church of Rome? If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck. Rome definitely passes the “duck test” of Revelation.


God will not permit this wicked woman to go unpunished. “Fallen, fallen is Babylon the great! She has become a dwelling place for demons, a haunt for every unclean spirit…For all nations have drunk the wine of the passion of her sexual immorality, and the kings of the earth have committed immorality with her…For this reason her plagues will come in a single day, death and mourning and famine, and she will be burned up with fire; for mighty is the Lord God who has judged her.” Rome, and all her false unity, is condemned by God.


Some evangelicals argue that there are multitudes of true born-again believers to be found within Catholicism, and say that this justifies rapprochement with Rome. There may be at any given time some Christians who are in the process of leaving Rome. But those who are truly trusting in Christ alone for salvation, and who are placing no confidence in the sacramental salvation of Rome, are not truly Catholic. God warns them, “Come out of her, my people, lest you take part in her sins.” Rev. 18:4. To remain in an idolatrous worship system, after receiving knowledge of the truth, is disobedient and foolish. 



Are You a Spiritual Terrorist?


Several months ago, I wrote an issue on the Charismatic Bridge to Rome. In the article, I mentioned South African “evangelical Anglican Bishop” Tony Palmer. Here is a link to another video, in which he states the following:

  • He and Pope Francis have covenanted to work for unity.
  • Francis consecrated Palmer to be a bridge to promote unity
  • It is a theological fact that we (Catholics and evangelicals) are one in Christ.
  • No denominational doctrine can destroy this fact.
  • Since 1999, the protest of Luther is over.
  • We are living in a post-Protestant era.
  • Even though our “Christian apartheid” is over, there are still many evangelicals who suffer from spiritual racism.
  • This is a sin against the cross; anything that causes division, when we elevate any doctrine, we place that above the cross.
  • The cross unites; that’s what makes us one – not doctrines.
  • Diversity is divine; it’s division that’s diabolical.
  • Christian unity is the basis of our credibility.
  • Division destroys our credibility.
  • Fear separates us; this fear is based on propaganda.
  • If there is no more protest, how can there be a Protestant Church?
  • Maybe now we are all Catholics again.
  • We now preach the same gospel.
  • We should throw more resources toward reconciliation than toward evangelism.
  • Otherwise, we are building walls without foundations.
  • I challenge you to find a bridge-builder, and back him or her.

My dear fellow Christians, I confess that I am a spiritual racist. I believe in spiritual apartheid. Not only that, I must be considered a spiritual terrorist in the eyes of the Pope, Tony Palmer, and his fellow ecumenists.


I lived the first ten years of my life in Buffalo, NY. In Buffalo there is a bridge to Canada called the “Peace Bridge.” The Pope, a/k/a the Pontiff or “bridge-builder” is seeking to lure unwary evangelicals across the “peace bridge” that spans the Tiber River into Rome – the “City of Man.” It is a frightful decision to abandon the evangel for the unity of Rome. It is said that “all things are possible with God.” But Heb. 6:5 says that it is impossible, in the case of those who have once tasted the heavenly gift and tasted the goodness of the word of God and the powers of the age to come, and then have fallen away, to restore them again to repentance. We need to do everything we can (with spiritual weapons) to blow up the “peace bridge” that leads to Rome. And we need to point Catholics to the “heavenly bridge” that crosses the river Jordan and leads to eternal life. That bridge is Christ, not the Roman pontiff.


Some of you, I’m sure, have seen the movie, Bridge on the River Kwai, the story of British POW’s forced to build a strategic bridge for the Japanese. One of the prisoners escapes, and eventually connects with a British Major in Ceylon. They return to Burma to plant dynamite and destroy the bridge. For all ex-Catholics, that should be our mission: having escaped the prison camp of Rome, we are to return and sabotage the strategic bridge leading back to the prison camp.


We live in the post-modern age of tolerance, where only the intolerant are not tolerated. What I have been arguing is probably considered “hate speech” in many countries. But the gospel is divisive and causes separation. The truncated gospel of “god has a wonderful plan for your life” is not the gospel. The true gospel is “repent, for the kingdom of God is at hand.” This gospel tells people they are wrong, and if they continue in their error they are bound for hell. In fact, they are condemned already. Despite the beliefs of the Pope and Tony Palmer, the protest is not over; the war is indeed still raging. May we be found to be good soldiers, persevering until the end.  



How can evangelicals answer the allegation of disobedient disunity? Some thoughts: 

  1. There exists a spiritual unity of all true Christians, despite appearances. This unity is based on the indwelling Spirit of Christ that binds them together.
  2. Even amid the diversity of evangelical churches, there is unity in essential matters, especially regarding justification.
  3. Even with numerous denominations, there are still marks of unity. David Murray, in the June 2014 issue of Tabletalk, lists various shades of cooperation: ecumenism, association, endorsement, and friendship. With Rome, there is an “all or nothing” attitude toward unity.
  4. The plan of God is to work through, and be glorified in, our weakness.
  5. There is no record in the NT of a super-hierarchy; there are geographical churches and even house churches.
  6. Unity in diversity is a display of God’s workmanship. God even uses separation to spread more widely His gospel.
  7. Disunity is unavoidable because of our sinful natures which are still present within us. Rome is delusional in claiming infallibility of teaching and the holiness of her adherents.
  8. Many small errors, spread out over numerous churches, is safer than one fatal error being enforced by a monolithic hierarchical structure. Sin is magnified in the Papacy.
  9. The Bible requires discernment by Christians, and calls for godly separation and church discipline.
  10. Challenges to unity promotes humility, patience and forbearance.
  11. No doctrine, no division; know doctrine, know division.
  12. “Do you think that I have come to give peace on earth? No, I tell you, but rather division.” Lk. 12:51.


Please check out the recommended books for this month: The History of the Papacy, by J.A. Wylie; The History of Protestantism, by J.A. Wylie. A Woman Rides the Beast, by Dave Hunt.


One Comment leave one →
  1. M.J. permalink
    July 2, 2014 6:24 pm

    I am a spiritual racist as Tony Palmer puts it. I emailed the good bishop at his ark community website. I told him how I felt about his unity. I got my email returned. Oh well. The truth hurts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: